Find and rank the defects in a planning assessment someone else wrote — an officer report, appeal statement or planning statement — for a reader deciding whether to act on them. Runs planning-report-quality, then reports only what is wrong and matters, ordered by severity, with a verbatim quote for each. Separates findings from observations, and treats a true-but-immaterial point as an observation rather than a fault. England-focused. Not legal advice; human review required.