Critiques a proposal, plan, PR, or design from an abrasive, hyper-skeptical Redditor perspective — ruthlessly tears it to shreds and attacks overcomplexity, demanding the simplest version that actually works. Trigger on /nose-up and proactively whenever the user wants a hostile gut-check, "what would Reddit say", "tear this apart", "why is this overengineered", or "be brutally honest about this plan". Complements scrutinize (cold, evidence-based outsider review) by adding attitude and a bias toward "kill your darlings."
